CNN
—
All eyes on Tuesday will probably be on special counsel Robert Hur, who investigated President Joe Biden’s mishandling of categorized paperwork and delivered a political bombshell together with his conclusions about Biden’s reminiscence.
The particular counsel is about to testify on the GOP-run Home Judiciary Committee, the place he’ll be peppered with questions on his 388-page report launched final month.
After a yearlong investigation, Hur concluded that Biden mishandled categorized materials and improperly disclosed categorized info as a non-public citizen. Nevertheless, Hur mentioned that there wasn’t sufficient proof to prosecute Bidenm, and that he wouldn’t have pursued expenses even when the Justice Division allowed him to indict a sitting president.
Nevertheless it was Hur’s evaluation of Biden’s cognitive skills that despatched shockwaves all through Washington. He described Biden as a “well-meaning, aged man with a poor reminiscence” in explaining the uphill battle prosecutors may face when making an attempt to persuade a possible jury that Biden was a prison.
Listed below are 4 key issues to search for in Tuesday’s high-stakes listening to:
What’s going to Hur say about Biden’s age and reminiscence?
Republicans will undoubtedly query Hur over Biden’s psychological acuity after his report painted a damaging portrait of the president’s reminiscence, which it known as “considerably restricted” and “hazy” at occasions.
Biden and his allies have forcefully rejected the depiction of a defective reminiscence, however Republicans shortly seized on the report back to argue he’s unfit to serve – particularly as they make Biden’s age a serious focus of assault within the 2024 presidential race. (At 81, Biden is the oldest US president in historical past, although Donald Trump is just a few years youthful at 77.)
Along with calling Biden an “aged man with a poor reminiscence,” the report mentioned that in the course of the president’s interview with Hur’s workplace in October, Biden didn’t keep in mind precisely when his son Beau died, or which years he served as vp below Barack Obama.
A visibly seething Biden responded later, telling reporters, “I’m well-meaning. And I’m an aged man. And I do know what the hell I’m doing.”
“How within the hell dare he increase that?” Biden requested of the report’s reference to Beau’s demise. “I don’t want anybody to remind me when he handed away.”
White Home officers and Biden’s private lawyer known as the report’s assertions concerning the president’s reminiscence inappropriate and incorrect, noting the interview came about within the fast aftermath of Hamas’ October 7 assault in opposition to Israel, and arguing that Biden was extremely engaged even with every thing else occurring.
Some Home Republicans have known as for the vp and the Cupboard to invoke the twenty fifth Modification to take away Biden from workplace in mild of what Hur mentioned about Biden’s psychological health, arguing that the president seems unable to carry out the duties of his workplace, although many different Republicans haven’t gone as far.
How does Hur differentiate Biden and Trump’s dealing with of categorized materials?
Hur will probably be testifying Tuesday at a congressional listening to about Biden’s mishandling of categorized paperwork. Two days later, there will probably be a court docket listening to in Florida about Trump’s allegedly unlawful mishandling of categorized paperwork, in the Mar-a-Lago case introduced by particular counsel Jack Smith.
The similarities and variations between the 2 probes – and the truth that Trump was indicted whereas Biden was not – have been the topic of intense political debate and bickering in Washington. (Trump has pleaded not responsible.)
Maybe probably the most potent line of assault for Democrats on Tuesday will probably be Hur’s personal clarification for why, primarily, Trump’s conduct was worse than Biden’s. He went out of his method in his report to notice the “materials distinction” between the 2 investigations, and the way Biden and Trump took totally different paths.
“After being given a number of probabilities to return categorized paperwork and keep away from prosecution, Mr. Trump allegedly did the other. … In distinction, Mr. Biden turned in categorized paperwork to the Nationwide Archives and the Division of Justice, consented to the search of a number of places together with his houses, sat for a voluntary interview, and in different methods cooperated with the investigation,” Hur wrote.
Will Hur additional lean into these variations whereas answering lawmakers’ questions? His tone on this, and the way in which he characterizes Trump’s conduct, will probably be carefully watched, particularly by Biden allies.
Nonetheless, Republicans are certain to grab on the truth that Trump was charged whereas Biden was not.
This feeds the narrative that Trump has put on the forefront of his marketing campaign – the baseless accusation that the Justice Division and legislation enforcement are being “weaponized” in opposition to him and different conservatives. He has used this argument as a sword to assault all 4 of his pending criminal cases.
Home Republicans are in search of Hur’s public testimony to offer recent momentum to their sputtering impeachment inquiry into Biden.
Of their subpoena to the Justice Department for paperwork associated to Hur’s probe forward of the listening to, Republicans linked Hur’s work to their very own investigation, saying they “are involved that President Biden might have retained delicate paperwork associated to particular international locations involving his household’s international enterprise dealings.”
The Justice Division supplied the Home Oversight and Judiciary committees with among the paperwork that Republicans subpoenaed, however not all of them – particularly the transcript and audio recordings of Biden’s interview with the particular counsel, in keeping with their letter obtained by CNN.
In keeping with the letter, the primary tranche features a December 2015 name sheet outlining the aim of a name between the then-Ukrainian prime minister and then-Vice President Biden, speaking factors and a non-verbatim transcript of that decision for lawmakers to view privately.
Republicans have sought to attach these paperwork to their impeachment inquiry, particularly to the false accusations that Biden abused his powers to get a prime Ukrainian prosecutor fired as a result of he was supposedly investigating a Ukrainian vitality firm, Burisma, which threatened the president’s son Hunter, who served on the board. These claims have been repeatedly debunked since they first emerged in 2019.
Hur’s report said that “no jury might moderately discover that the substance of the decision between Mr. Biden and the Ukrainian Prime Minister was nationwide protection info. The 2 exchanged pleasantries and the Prime Minister heaped reward upon Mr. Biden for his December 9, 2015 speech to Ukraine’s parliament. They didn’t have interaction in a substantive coverage dialogue.”
The Justice Division additionally supplied Home Republicans with the communications between the division and the Govt Workplace of the President or President Biden’s private counsel over Hur’s report. Republicans subpoenaed these paperwork as a result of they declare to be involved that restrictions have been positioned on Hur to cease him from trying into info that would hyperlink the president to his household’s international enterprise dealings.
After 15 months, 1000’s of financial institution information, paperwork and greater than 40 interviews with Biden relations, enterprise associates, administration personnel, Division of Justice officers and Inner Income Service whistleblowers, Republicans have didn’t uncover proof to their core allegations that the president used his authorities powers to personally profit financially or to serve his household’s international enterprise pursuits.
Since Republicans reclaimed the Home majority in 2023, all investigative roads had run via the president’s son. However Hunter Biden failed to offer Republicans with a smoking gun in his deposition last month and as a substitute turned the most recent witness to inform Republicans the president was not concerned in any of the household’s international enterprise dealings.
How will Hur deal with his flip within the highlight?
Robert Hur is just not a family identify – that is possible the largest second of his profession.
It seems that he participated in only one White House news conference in the course of the Trump administration, when he was the US legal professional in Maryland from April 2018 till February 2021. His supply was robust on the White Home podium, however there’s a world of distinction between a information convention and a congressional grilling in entrance of lawmakers in search of their very own viral second.
Hur would be the third particular counsel to testify earlier than the Home Judiciary Committee up to now 5 years, and the earlier two examples supply totally different attainable methods for Hur.
Robert Mueller testified in 2019 concerning the Trump-Russia investigation, and gave halting testimony through which he repeatedly dodged questions by telling lawmakers to search out the solutions in his report. He even declined to learn aloud sections of his report when requested by Democratic lawmakers, who have been hoping to solicit soundbites about Trump’s misdeeds. The listening to left many questioning whether or not something was even achieved.
John Durham, who investigated the origins of the Russia probe, was extra prepared to supply substantive solutions to lawmakers’ questions when he testified last year and was open to partaking with lawmakers. In a single memorable second, he went out of his solution to defend former Lawyer Normal Invoice Barr from Trump’s public assaults, regardless that he might have strictly caught to what was printed in his report.
Hur’s method will decide how straightforward, or exhausting, it’s for lawmakers to extract the political moments that they need.
By together with commentary in his report about Biden’s psychological state – which some authorized consultants and White House lawyers have mentioned wasn’t warranted – Hur confirmed that he isn’t afraid to step on a political landmine. Nevertheless, he’ll be compelled to elucidate his conclusions about Biden’s feebleness simply 5 days after the president stunned many on Capitol Hill together with his fiery State of the Union performance.