A model of this story appeared in CNN’s What Issues publication. To get it in your inbox, join free here.
CNN
—
Whereas the 2024 presidential race appears set in stone as a rematch between President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump, it’s additionally true that issues occur.
Again in November 1872, as an illustration, the newspaper writer and Democratic presidential candidate Horace Greeley died after Election Day however earlier than the casting of Electoral Faculty votes. Whereas it didn’t have an effect on the end result – President Ulysses S. Grant simply received reelection – Greeley’s dying created the troublesome query of what to do with the 66 Electoral Faculty votes he had received.
Most electors, assembly in state capitols, didn’t solid votes for the deceased Greeley, however reasonably cut up them among four other candidates. Congress did not count the three votes that had been solid for a useless man.
Within the greater than 150 years since Greeley’s dying, there have been two constitutional amendments associated to presidential succession, however there’s nonetheless some grey space with regards to an unexpected occasion that strikes a presidential nominee or candidate.
Right this moment, polling suggests voters are nervous that each Trump and Biden are too outdated for the job. Trump might be 78 on Election Day in November, and Biden will flip 82 later that month. With out being macabre, it’s price figuring out what would occur if, for no matter purpose, both man was unable to proceed with the race.
Changing both man on the poll – not that anybody is critically speaking about it – can be a messy and chaotic course of that might uncover divisions and disagreements inside the political events. Nobody is aware of for positive what would occur if a candidate died or for some purpose wanted to withdraw from the race.
Right here’s a take a look at the principles for Republicans and Democrats as they at present stand.
What occurs if a candidate can’t proceed his or her marketing campaign?
The method of changing a presidential candidate very a lot will depend on when the emptiness happens – through the major course of and earlier than the celebration conference; through the conference or after the conference; or earlier than or after individuals vote in November.
Whereas Trump and Biden are in complete command of the respective races to be the Republican and Democratic presidential candidates, that course of will play out between now and June as states conduct primaries and caucuses and assign delegates primarily based on the outcomes.
If a emptiness on both aspect occurs earlier than most of these primaries had been to happen, it’s potential that one other candidate might emerge and rack up some delegates. However since submitting deadlines have already handed for a lot of primaries, it’s unlikely any single candidate, aside from Trump or Biden, might rack up sufficient delegates to win the nomination earlier than celebration conventions this summer time.
It’s, nonetheless, potential that states might determine to delay their primaries, according to Elaine Kamarck, a member of the Democratic Nationwide Committee guidelines committee and a senior fellow on the Brookings Establishment who has studied the difficulty. Republicans will maintain their conference in Milwaukee in July, and Democrats will maintain theirs simply to the south in Chicago in August.
Most delegates could have been awarded by the tip of March. Biden has not confronted critical opposition within the Democratic major, has received each delegate at stake thus far and must win no less than 1,968 of three,934 to safe the nomination on the primary poll of voting.
On the Republican aspect, Trump has received each contest thus far and finally wants 1,215 of two,429 delegates. His high rival, former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley, is much behind Trump within the delegate race.
What if a emptiness happens after the primaries and earlier than or through the conference?
If the main candidate was to drop out of the marketing campaign after most primaries and even through the conference, particular person delegates would seemingly determine the celebration’s nominee on the conference flooring.
That will shine a highlight on the usually area of interest query of who these precise delegates are.
There can be a messy political battle in each state over who would get to be a delegate (if the emptiness occurred earlier than a lot of these individuals had been chosen) after which who they’d finally help. Even individuals who didn’t run major campaigns might finally be thought of.
You may assume, as an illustration, that Vice President Kamala Harris can be a high contender to be on the poll if, for some purpose, Biden left the race. On the similar time, given Haley’s weak spot in primaries, it appears unlikely that Republicans would coalesce round her if Trump was unable to run.
On the Democratic aspect, there would even be one other group to think about: the “superdelegates,” a gaggle of about 700 senior celebration leaders and elected officers who’re mechanically delegates to the conference primarily based on their place. Below regular celebration guidelines, they will’t vote on the primary poll if they might swing the nomination, however they’re free to vote on subsequent ballots.
The trendy major and caucus system advanced solely in current generations as voters demanded extra involvement within the nominating course of.
The election that sparked change was in 1968, when President Lyndon B. Johnson determined to not run after an embarrassing end in New Hampshire’s major. Johnson received, however simply barely.
When he dropped out of the presidential race, it set off a chaotic sprint to switch him. One candidate who jumped within the race, Sen. Robert F. Kennedy, was assassinated in Los Angeles simply after profitable the California major, creating the troublesome query of who his delegates ought to help.
The last word Democratic winner that yr, Vice President Hubert Humphrey, amassed his delegates in states that didn’t conduct primaries, securing sufficient help to win the nomination.
Violence on the streets of Chicago across the conference marred the occasion and helped encourage the system of primaries and caucuses we have now immediately the place voters choose presidential candidates by means of delegates sure to help a particular candidate.
What if a candidate left the race after the conference?
It will take a drastic occasion for a candidate to go away the race within the few months between a celebration’s nominating conference in the summertime and the final election in November.
Democrats and Republicans have barely totally different strategies of coping with this chance. You may think about the tip consequence would most likely be that the working mate stepped as much as be on the final election poll, however that isn’t essentially assured.
Democrats – The Democratic Nationwide Committee is empowered to fill a emptiness on the nationwide ticket after the conference below celebration guidelines, after the celebration chair consults with Democratic governors and congressional management.
Republicans – If a emptiness happens on the Republican aspect, the Republican Nationwide Committee can both reconvene the nationwide conference or choose a brand new candidate itself.
An in-depth Congressional Research Service memo additionally notes that if an incumbent president turns into incapacitated after profitable the celebration’s nomination, the twenty fifth Modification would elevate the vp to the presidency, however celebration guidelines would decide who rises to grow to be the celebration’s nominee.
Neither celebration, in line with CRS, requires that the presidential candidate’s working mate be elevated to the highest of the ticket, however that might clearly be the probably state of affairs.
Has a candidate ever left the race after the conference?
In fashionable occasions, per CRS, the Democrat working for vp in 1972, Sen. Thomas Eagleton, was pressured to step apart after the conference after it was found that he was handled for psychological sickness (1972 was a really totally different time! Right this moment, fortunately, there’s not almost the stigma hooked up to psychological well being).
The DNC truly wanted to convene a gathering to affirm Sargent Shriver as Democratic nominee George McGovern’s second-choice working mate.
If a president-elect was to die, timing is once more necessary.
Below the Structure, it’s electors assembly in state capitols who technically solid votes for the presidency. Whereas some states require that they vote for the winner of the election of their state, in others they’ve leeway.
The CRS memo, which cites a number of congressional hearings on the topic, suggests it might clearly make sense for a vice president-elect to easily assume the position of president-elect, however the legislation itself is murky.
Below the twentieth Modification, if a president-elect dies, his or her working mate, the vice president-elect, turns into president.
There may very well be some query, as an illustration, about when precisely an individual turns into president-elect. Is it after the electors meet in December, or after Congress meets to depend Electoral Faculty votes on January 6?