Editor’s Be aware: Delving into the archives of popular culture historical past, “Remember When?” is a CNN Fashion sequence providing a nostalgic take a look at the movie star outfits that outlined their eras.
CNN
—
Singing concerning the perils of fame, being dragged out from beneath a fallen chandelier then bleeding to loss of life in entrance of a roomful of celebrities: Girl Gaga was not shy about making her debut on the MTV Video Music Awards.
The 12 months was 2009 — many will bear in mind it because the 12 months rapper Ye (previously Kanye West) stage-crashed 19-year-old Taylor Swift and steered her award for Greatest Feminine Video ought to have gone to Beyoncé as an alternative. However by no means one to be overshadowed, Girl Gaga, then 23, made some popular culture historical past of her personal that night time.
Her rendition of “Paparazzi” — lamenting each unrequited love and the sinister results of hounding tabloids — has gone down within the mists of Gaga legend; not least as a result of a scarcity of high-quality footage means followers should resort to watching grainy screen-recorded variations circulated on social media.
Over the restricted variety of pixels, Gaga will be seen at first of the efficiency in an all-white ensemble: a bejeweled, uneven lace bodysuit and matching cape, thigh-high boots, a feathered Keko Hainswheeler headpiece and strings of glinting pearls. As she staggered again from her piano on the music’s crescendo, nonetheless, an audible gasp swept the room as thick blood instantly seemed to be pouring from her stomach.
“I’m your greatest fan, I’ll observe you till you like me,” Gaga wailed desperately, her once-pristine outfit now daubed in scarlet. She ended the quantity suspended above the stage, ‘useless,’ as extra blood dripped from her eyes.
“(It) offers me chills each time I watch it,” Olivia Rodrigo instructed MTV in 2021. “I feel Girl Gaga is the perfect performer of our era.” The “Drivers License” singer appeared to take notes. At this 12 months’s Grammy Awards, she started to ‘bleed’ from clenched fists whereas performing her hit “vampire,” spreading faux blood throughout her arms and neck because the music progressed.
Rodrigo wasn’t the one younger artist impressed by Gaga’s gore: TikTok sensation-turned pop star Addison Rae recreated the blood-soaked search for Halloween in 2022, whereas fellow singers Madison Beer and Reneé Rapp have cited “Paparazzi” as one of many VMAs’ most iconic moments. “That was probably the most impactful efficiency of my youth,” Beer instructed MTV in 2021. “It shifted tradition perpetually,” Rapp agreed in a separate interview two years later. “Nothing was ever the identical.”
However not everybody was bought.
In a bit printed instantly after the VMAs, The Every day Mail accused Gaga of getting “garnered column inches primarily for her style decisions quite than her raunchy pop music,” describing Gaga herself as “outrageous,” “eccentric” and her outfits as “weird.”
“She accepted her award for Greatest New Artist in a face-obscuring purple get-up that might have made even Isabella Blow arch her eyebrows,” wrote a equally skeptical Jon Caramanica, critic on the New York Occasions.
Web page Six was additionally not proud of Gaga “cramming loopy down our faces,” her “Catholicism artwork work” or her “lazy” singing which, mixed, had the reviewer “reaching for the (quick ahead) button.”
However Gaga’s blood-soaked bodysuit was greater than a gimmick — it was an announcement of autonomy, and a critique of the very establishment she was performing for.
“Once they wished me to be attractive, or they wished me to be pop, I all the time… put some absurd spin on it that made me really feel like I used to be nonetheless in management,” she instructed studio musician Nick Movshon in “Gaga: 5 Foot Two,” a 2017 documentary concerning the artist she additionally co-produced. “If I’m gonna be attractive on the VMAs and sing concerning the paparazzi, I’m gonna do it whereas I’m bleeding to loss of life and reminding you of what fame did to Marilyn Monroe… and what it did to Anna Nicole Smith, and what it did to — yeah, who.” (The movie’s director, Chris Moukarbel, later confirmed the ‘who’ was Amy Winehouse.)
“Paparazzi” was Gaga’s rebuttal of the press and followers’ insidious demand to personal — and inevitably eliminate — feminine stars. Chappell Roan — who has lengthy been in comparison with Gaga for her personal theatrical music and style — shot to meteoric stardom this summer time after her songs “HOT TO GO!” and “Good Luck, Babe!” went viral. Since then, nonetheless, she too has known as out the invasive nature of movie star after followers started asking for pictures together with her on the street and discovering out the place her relations labored.
“Individuals have began to be freaks,” she stated on TikTok star Drew Afaulo’s podcast “The Remark Part.” “I’ve pumped the brakes on, truthfully, something to make me extra recognized.” She additionally took to her Instagram and TikTok accounts to reiterate her level, stating: “I’m allowed to say ‘no’ to creepy habits.” Whether or not Roan — who’s making her VMA debut this 12 months after being nominated for Greatest New Artist and PUSH Efficiency of the Yr — will select to make her personal sartorial assertion stays to be seen.
In addition to taking house the Greatest New Artist trophy in 2009, Gaga went on to win one other two, for Greatest Particular Results and Greatest Artwork Path. Within the 15 years since, she’s provoked numerous extra gasp-worthy moments, together with the well-known meat dress she wore the very subsequent 12 months. However that night time on the VMAs, Gaga marked herself as a pop power to be reckoned with, and sarcastically gave the press all that they had ever wished: a second to speak about for years to return.