CNN
—
If there was one signal this week of Vice President Kamala Harris’ place atop the Democratic ticket having improved the get together’s model, it was the presence of so many Senate candidates taking the stage at its conference in Chicago.
Notably, three of probably the most weak senators skipped the Democratic Nationwide Conference. However nominees in Michigan, Arizona, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Maryland and Texas have been available for at the very least a part of the week, with a lot of them talking the same night as Harris.
Whereas Harris has improved on President Joe Biden’s standing in lots of states — placing Nevada and Arizona again in play, for instance — the fundamental form of the essential Senate races that can decide the bulk is identical. Democrats have been overperforming the highest of the ticket when Biden was the nominee they usually nonetheless are below Harris.
However Democrats are going through an extremely unfavorable map this yr, defending seats in locations that former President Donald Trump received by comfy margins and presidential battlegrounds that he narrowly misplaced in 2020. Assuming Republicans choose up West Virginia, the place Sen. Joe Manchin is retiring, the get together simply must win the White Home or choose up yet one more Senate seat to safe the bulk.
And beneath the topline development of Democratic overperformance (thus far), there are rising variations amongst a few of these races which have resulted in shifts to this month’s rating of the Senate seats most probably to flip, which relies on CNN’s reporting, in addition to fundraising, polling and spending information.
The highest three states most probably to vary arms — West Virginia, Montana and Ohio — aren’t budging. After these three, the following most probably are actually open seats the place Democrats are on protection: Michigan and Arizona. Seats with out incumbents are nearly all the time tougher to defend, partly as a result of the nominees don’t have as well-known manufacturers to assist buck any nationwide headwinds. These two seats slide above Nevada, the place Sen. Jacky Rosen is working for a second time period and which had previously been No. 4.
Whereas Harris has been driving a number of weeks of momentum (and, if historical past is any information, will possible see some form of post-convention polling bump), there’s nonetheless a protracted street to November — with a looming September 10 debate in opposition to Trump and guarantees to ultimately sit for a one-on-one interview, amongst different issues, that might shake up the 2024 race.
And on the Senate degree, as extra voters tune into the election heading into the standard post-Labor Day marketing campaign season and extra Republican spending ramps up, each events anticipate numbers of their races to tighten. There’s just one Democratic pickup goal on the listing (Texas), whereas Republicans are nonetheless optimistic about expanding the map into New Mexico, which has not made the listing.
The rankings under characterize a snapshot of the place the race for the Senate stands now — and never essentially the place it could be heading — so we’ll examine again on the next contests as issues develop.
No information right here: West Virginia remains to be the seat most probably to flip — a actuality Democrats have lengthy acknowledged.
It might have been a tricky seat to carry even with Manchin, however with out the Democrat-turned-independent senator working for reelection, Republican Gov. Jim Justice is poised to be the following senator from a state Trump is anticipated to hold by double digits.
Sen. Jon Tester stays probably the most endangered Democrat working for reelection. In a state Trump twice carried by vital margins, he’ll possible must overperform Harris by double digits. That’s a particularly tall order, however the seven-fingered grime farmer has a historical past of defying the partisan lean of his state. What’s totally different this yr, nevertheless, is that it’s the primary time he’s on the poll concurrently Trump. Republican advertisements repeatedly performed footage of the senator saying he endorsed Biden. And though Tester didn’t attend the DNC and stated this week he won’t be endorsing within the presidential race, Republicans are persevering with to try to tie him to an administration that’s deeply unpopular in Montana.
Whereas Republicans attempt to nationalize the race, Democrats try to underscore the contrasts between Tester and his GOP challenger Tim Sheehy, a retired Navy SEAL. They’re working an analogous playbook in opposition to him as they did in opposition to Matt Rosendale in 2018, attempting to color him as an out-of-state millionaire who would threaten entry to public lands and questioning his ranching credentials. Sheehy settled in Montana in 2014 after leaving the army, and Republicans argue these carpetbagging assaults solely go thus far now that there are extra conservative transplants within the state after the pandemic.
One new wild card within the race: Montana will now have an abortion measure on the November poll. Democratic Senatorial Marketing campaign Committee Chairman Gary Peters expressed confidence in Chicago final week that the referendum would increase Tester.
Democratic Sen. Sherrod Brown’s place on the listing has been constant — apart from Tester, he’s probably the most weak senator as a result of he, too, is working for reelection in a Trump state. He’s possible in a barely safer place than Tester given Trump’s narrower margins within the Buckeye State. First elected to the Senate in 2006, Brown’s model of progressive populism has allowed him to defy Ohio’s rising redness. And he’s not shy about touting his work throughout the aisle. “That’s why I’m partnering with Republicans to dam China from buying extra farmland,” he says in a recent spot about defending Ohio jobs and farms. One other features a Republican sheriff vouching for Brown’s efforts to combat fentanyl coming throughout the border — a frequent tactic this yr for Democratic incumbents attempting to get forward of GOP assaults.
This yr, Brown is up in opposition to Republican businessman Bernie Moreno, whom Democrats boosted within the GOP major as a result of they thought he’d be the weakest opponent. They could have been appropriate. The automotive dealership proprietor trailed Brown even when Biden was atop the ticket. That doesn’t imply that Brown is protected, nevertheless. Moreno is simply now stepping up his advert spending, which is able to possible make issues extra aggressive. He’s working a spot with the Nationwide Republican Senatorial Committee that focuses on immigration — particularly blaming Brown for the border disaster and attempting to tie him to Harris. Within the distinction spot, he reminds voters that he’s backed by Trump — a probably highly effective argument on this state even when Moreno himself isn’t well-known.
The race to exchange retiring Democratic Sen. Debbie Stabenow strikes up two spots on the listing as a result of it’s an open seat, which is often tougher to defend. When Biden was nonetheless defying his get together’s entreaties to step apart, Democratic Rep. Elissa Slotkin raised alarm bells in regards to the course of the competition on this essential blue wall state. The three-term congresswoman has praised the brand new vitality Harris has dropped at the race. However as a congresswoman working statewide for the primary time, she’ll face a difficult race in opposition to Republican former Rep. Mike Rogers.
Slotkin, a former CIA analyst, is a formidable fundraiser whose advertisements tout her service below the Bush administration. However Rogers additionally brings nationwide safety expertise to the race as the previous chairman of the Home Intelligence Committee. Slotkin went negative in opposition to him as quickly as he received the August 6 GOP major, blasting him as a profession politician who’s sorted himself. The DSCC is putting an analogous tone in an ad referred to as “Florida man” (a nod to his Sunshine State property) that claims he’s “in it for Mike, not for Michigan.”
The day Slotkin spoke on the DNC, the NRSC debuted a new ad in opposition to her that includes a Republican sheriff saying that regulation enforcement wants a senator “who has our again.” (Whereas the advert assaults her of voting in opposition to GOP-sponsored border security measures final yr, she supported this yr’s bipartisan border safety invoice that Trump leaned on the GOP to kill.) Republicans are additionally trying to tie her to Covid aid funds gone incorrect.
Slotkin was at 46% to Rogers’ 43% amongst possible voters in an early August New York Times/Siena College poll, with extra independents breaking for the Republican. Harris was at 50% to Trump’s 46%. (Each outcomes have been throughout the margin of error.)
Arizona, one other open-seat race Democrats try to defend, stays at No. 5. Nevertheless it’s now above Nevada due to the open seat and since it’s a state the place the border — a powerful subject for Republicans — is entrance and heart.
Sen. Kyrsten Sinema, who grew to become an impartial however nonetheless caucuses with Democrats, shouldn’t be working for reelection. Her departure from the race gave technique to a two-way matchup between Democratic Rep. Ruben Gallego, a Marine veteran, and Republican Kari Lake, a Trump ally who hasn’t let go of claims that she truly received the 2022 gubernatorial election.
Democrats’ victory right here in 2020 — for each the White Home and the Senate — established Arizona as a purple state. It appeared much less aggressive on the prime of the ticket when Biden was nonetheless working, however Harris appears to have put the Solar Belt States again in competition. A New York Times/Siena poll in mid-August discovered a decent race between her and Trump.
Even when Trump was forward, although, some Republicans have been anxious about Lake, who’s confirmed to be a controversial candidate unwilling to reasonable a lot of her positions to enchantment to the state’s suburban and impartial voters. She’s even alienated members of her personal get together, which the DSCC has tried to focus on in an ad that performs footage of her attacking the late Sen. John McCain. However she scored a robust endorsement this month from former Gov. Doug Ducey, who had backed her 2022 major challenger. His help speaks volumes in regards to the get together’s willingness to get behind Lake if it means they may be capable of maintain this seat once more.
Gallego led Lake by 9 factors amongst possible voters in that very same New York Occasions/Siena ballot. However by the numbers, that is nonetheless a tricky state for Democrats, the place Gallego — a former member of the Congressional Progressive Caucus — might want to win over some voters from throughout the aisle. He was pulling 12% of registered Republicans and greater than half of independents within the Occasions ballot. That is one other state the place Democrats hope a poll measure on abortion rights may increase their possibilities.
Nevada, the place Rosen is working for a second time period, drops down two spots this month — partly as a result of Harris has improved the get together’s fortunes on the prime of the ticket.
As an incumbent, Rosen could also be in a greater place than some Democrats elsewhere who’re working statewide for the primary time. She doesn’t have the sturdy model that her colleagues in Montana or Ohio do, however she led Republican Sam Brown by 9 factors amongst possible voters in a New York Times/Siena poll. That margin will undoubtedly tighten as extra voters get to know Brown, an Military veteran who first ran for workplace in Texas, then misplaced final yr’s GOP Senate major in Nevada. And it’s nonetheless powerful terrain for Democrats, with a transient inhabitants and demographics that could be transferring away from the get together.
However abortion can be on the poll in Nevada, a state the place Democrats consider reproductive rights are significantly salient. Brown’s messaging hints at that, too — he and his spouse have spoken about her resolution to have an abortion when she was 24 and single, and Brown has stated that he’d “shut the door” on backing a nationwide ban. He additionally stated he helps the Nevada law that enables abortions as much as 24 weeks. Democrats, nevertheless, have tried going after inconsistencies in his abortion stance, together with his support for extra restrictive laws in Texas.
Democratic Sen. Bob Casey’s seat stays the seventh most probably to flip. The three-term Democrat has loved an edge over GOP challenger Dave McCormick for a lot of this yr, and that’s nonetheless the case as he’s continued to overperform the highest of the ticket on this essential battleground.
As of mid-August, Casey led McCormick 52% to 44% amongst possible voters in a Quinnipiac University survey. (Harris was at 48% to Trump’s 45% amongst possible voters.) And a New York Times/Siena poll taken across the similar time confirmed Casey putting above 50% — a notable threshold for the incumbent, even when his 14-point edge amongst possible voters in that ballot might be too rosy for the Democrat.
Casey, a widely known incumbent with a well-recognized final title in Pennsylvania politics, was profitable 14% of registered Republicans in that Occasions ballot and greater than half of independents. He and his Democratic allies have been attacking McCormick, who misplaced final yr’s GOP Senate nod, over his business ties to China as a former hedge fund government. The Casey marketing campaign is even using sound of Trump throughout that 2022 major calling McCormick, whom he’s endorsed this yr, a “Wall Road Republican” and “completely the candidate of firms and particular pursuits.”
Underscoring McCormick’s problem, 37% of voters within the Quinnipiac survey stated they hadn’t heard sufficient about him to type an opinion. However that additionally represents a possibility for the Republican to develop, particularly as his thousands and thousands — and people of his allies — start to saturate the airwaves. They’re hitting Casey arduous on immigration and attempting to tie him to the Biden-Harris administration on the border and inflation.
Democratic Sen. Tammy Baldwin’s appearance with Harris at her first marketing campaign rally because the presidential nominee stated quite a bit about how the change on the prime of the ticket relieved some congressional candidates. The 2-term senator, who’s going through her best reelection, hadn’t appeared with Biden at his post-debate rally within the state.
She’s up in opposition to Republican Eric Hovde, who has put $13 million of his personal cash into his marketing campaign and shortly pivoted from attempting to tie her to Biden to attempting to tether her to Harris. Even when Biden was the nominee, although, Baldwin was holding her personal right here as a widely known incumbent who visits rural and conservative components of the state. In a mid-August New York Times/Siena poll, she led Hovde 51% to 44% amongst possible voters, whereas Harris (50%) and Trump (46%) have been in a better race. In an earlier Marquette Law School poll, taken simply after Biden dropped out of the race, Baldwin was at 52% to Hovde’s 47% amongst possible voters.
As they’re in opposition to different self-funding Republicans this yr, Democrats are attacking Hovde — the CEO of Sunwest Financial institution — as an out-of-state millionaire with a house in Laguna Seaside. “We now have a Inexperienced County. We now have a Brown County. We don’t have an Orange County,” is a favourite stump line of Baldwin’s, alluding to Hovde beforehand being named one of the most influential people within the Southern California county.
Hovde is that includes his spouse in a current ad, calling out Baldwin for what she says is the senator’s “soiled marketing campaign.” However the spot underscores a concern of some Republicans — that their nominee has spent an excessive amount of time reacting and never sufficient time speaking about points that matter to voters. He’s additionally attempting to humanize himself in new spots, highlighting his prognosis with a number of sclerosis at age 27.
Texas is the one Democratic offensive alternative on this listing. Rep. Colin Allred is attempting to knock off GOP Sen. Ted Cruz in a reliably crimson state. And though it’s nonetheless a longshot, Texas slides up one spot this month given nationwide Democrats’ enhancing fortunes in another locations with Harris main the ticket.
There’s been loads of buzz (and cash) round earlier efforts to defeat Cruz, however Democrats suppose that Allred, as a former NFL participant who flipped a GOP district in 2018, is a extra viable challenger. He’s persistently stored polling shut this summer season. About 47% of possible voters stated they’d again Cruz, whereas 45% stated Allred in a University of Houston/YouGov poll. Harris trailed Trump by 5 factors in the identical survey — an enchancment over Biden’s place within the state earlier this summer season.
Allred, who additionally spoke on the DNC, is one other Democrat hoping the difficulty of abortion — particularly, the backlash to Texas’ six-week ban — may assist him win over voters who may not have been in any other case inclined to vote blue. “It’s gotten extra harmful to be a girl in Texas,” an ob-gyn says in a single Allred digital spot. “And it’s Ted Cruz’s fault,” provides one other. (As a senator in Washington, Cruz didn’t truly vote for Texas’ laws, though he has defended it.) Cruz, in the meantime, is leaning into the border, arguing in a contrast spot that additionally compares himself to Texas Toast that he’s the one preventing for the state.
10. Maryland
Harris’ ascendance to the highest of the ticket has boosted what was already sturdy enthusiasm amongst Black lady in Maryland for sending Angela Alsobrooks to the Senate to exchange retiring Sen. Ben Cardin. And that’s essential, Baltimore Mayor Brandon Scott informed CNN in Chicago final week, due to how key Black ladies are to the Democratic vote on this overwhelmingly blue state.
Biden carried it by greater than 30 factors in 2020, so it was by no means a query of whether or not a Democrat would win the presidential race right here. Maryland first joined the listing of Senate seats most probably to flip due to the candidacy of Larry Hogan, who left two phrases as governor as a preferred Republican within the state. And whereas there hasn’t been any polling right here that meets CNN requirements for the reason that major, this race is transferring down one spot for now, largely due to the passion for Harris and the way intently it’s now tied to Alsobrooks, a mentee of the vp who touted each of their prosecutorial backgrounds throughout a keynote tackle on the DNC.
Whereas the conference drew consideration to the historical past Alsobooks would make as the primary Black particular person Maryland sends to the Senate (and solely the third Black lady elected to the chamber), she — like Harris — has been leaning extra into points than her identification. A recent ad, for instance, touts that she oversaw a drop in crime.
Hogan is attempting to distance himself from the nationwide GOP. In an ad from his marketing campaign and the NRSC, for instance, he says he’ll restore a girl’s proper to decide on and “combat the intense Venture 2025” — notable rhetoric for a Republican that sounds much more just like the language heard in Chicago final week. Nationwide Democrats, in the meantime, are arguing that Hogan could be a 51st vote for Republicans within the Senate, highlighting his endorsement from Trump. (Hogan has stated he’s not voting for Trump and isn’t interested in his backing.)