Washington
CNN
—
Senate Republicans voted Tuesday to dam a invoice that may assure entry to in vitro fertilization nationwide –- as Democrats highlight the difficulty within the run-up to the November elections.
Democrats introduced the invoice again to the Senate flooring after Republicans beforehand blocked the measure from advancing in June.
Many Republicans have criticized the Democrat-led laws as pointless overreach and a political present vote, whereas saying they do assist IVF.
The vote is a part of a broader push by Senate Democrats to attract a distinction with Republicans over reproductive well being care because the 2024 elections method.
It additionally gave Democrats a possibility to place Republicans on the spot after GOP presidential nominee Donald Trump stated in August that, if elected, he would implement a policy to require both the federal government or insurance coverage corporations to pay for IVF therapy. Democrats have questioned the sincerity of the proposal.
Senate Majority Chief Chuck Schumer on Monday pressed for Republicans to affix Democrats in voting to advance the IVF invoice.
“We’re already starting to listen to the identical drained and predictable and unconvincing excuses from our Republican colleagues in search of a method to vote in opposition to IVF protections,” Schumer stated. “To my Republican colleagues, when you actually assist IVF, then vote for a invoice that truly protects IVF by means of the letter of the legislation. Republicans can’t declare to be pro-family on the one hand, whereas then voting in opposition to IVF safety payments then again.”
Senate Republican Whip John Thune was requested final week if Trump’s feedback on IVF protection make issues harder for GOP senators after they vote on the invoice.
“I don’t know of any Republicans not favor of IVF,” he stated. “The mandate half, that’s a difficult subject for plenty of causes, not the least of which is what it does to insurance coverage prices. We put loads of mandates on insurance coverage corporations as it’s already.”
He known as Schumer’s transfer a “present vote” and stated he expects “sturdy dialog” in his convention.
The laws the Senate took up – the Proper to IVF Act – would enshrine into federal legislation a proper for people to obtain IVF therapy in addition to for docs to offer therapy, which might override any try on the state stage to limit entry.
The invoice seeks to make IVF therapy extra reasonably priced by mandating protection for fertility remedies underneath employer-sponsored insurance coverage and sure public insurance policy. It might additionally increase protection of fertility remedies, together with IVF, underneath US navy service members and veterans’ well being care.
The IVF legislative package deal was launched by Democratic Sen. Tammy Duckworth of Illinois together with Patty Murray of Washington state and Cory Booker of New Jersey.
Entry to IVF got here into the nationwide highlight after Alabama’s Supreme Courtroom stated, in a first-of-its-kind ruling earlier this year, that frozen embryos are youngsters and those that destroy them may be held chargeable for wrongful demise – a choice that reproductive rights advocates warned may have a chilling impact on infertility treatments.
Whereas the state’s legislature took action aimed at protecting IVF within the wake of the ruling, Democrats argue that this is just one instance of how entry to reproductive well being care is underneath menace throughout the nation.
Senate Republicans have tried to place ahead alternate proposals associated to IVF.
GOP Sen. Rick Scott of Florida went to the ground on Monday evening to aim to move a invoice geared toward making IVF extra reasonably priced, by unanimous consent. Democratic Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon objected, and as an alternative urged their colleagues to assist Democrats’ invoice throughout Tuesday’s vote.
The Home model of Scott’s invoice is sponsored by GOP Rep. Kat Cammack of Florida The laws doesn’t go so far as the Democrats’ plan to increase protection of IVF, however it might double contribution limits for Well being Financial savings Accounts and decouple these accounts from excessive deductible insurance policy in an effort to make it simpler to afford the process.
One other Senate GOP invoice geared toward addressing issues about IVF was launched earlier this 12 months. Sens. Katie Britt and Ted Cruz’s laws, known as the IVF Safety Act, has been criticized by Democrats who argue that its language leaves the door open to potential restrictions sooner or later, although it does say that states who prohibit entry to IVF wouldn’t be eligible for Medicaid funding.
CNN’s Aaron Pellish contributed to this report.