New York
CNN
—
In 2003, Purple Lobster ran an “Endless Crab” promotion. The all-you-can-eat deal backfired spectacularly.
Purple Lobster misjudged simply what number of seafood lovers would pour into eating places round the US and replenish their stomachs with kilos of candy, juicy crab legs drenched in lemon and dipped in melted butter. Whereas it was a scrumptious deal for patrons, it was horrible for the corporate: Purple Lobster misplaced $3.3 million in seven weeks.
“It wasn’t the second serving to on all-you-can-eat, however the third” that damage income, a Purple Lobster govt mentioned on the time to analysts.
Quick ahead 20 years, and Purple Lobster made a virtually similar mistake, however with shrimp — and below international possession that brought on a cascade of issues for the corporate.
Final summer season, Purple Lobster turned $20 infinite shrimp right into a everlasting merchandise on the menu, as an alternative of a conventional limited-time provide.
The deal was once again too popular, and Purple Lobster was unprepared for its prospects’ insatiable lust for discounted shellfish.
Purple Lobster’s main shareholder Thai Union, a Bangkok-based canned seafood firm, misplaced $11 million. “We must be way more cautious,” a Thai Union govt mentioned.
“They didn’t have the suitable administration firm in place,” mentioned John Gordon, a restaurant business analyst.
Limitless crab and infinite shrimp offers alone didn’t doom Purple Lobster — they have been simply two missteps in a protracted spiral for a series that was as soon as an business pioneer. Purple Lobster is now reportedly contemplating submitting for chapter safety to restructure its debt and shed a few of its 650 US areas. The chain has tapped a restructuring skilled as its chief govt, a doable indicator of an impending chapter.
Purple Lobster and Thai Union didn’t reply to CNN’s requests for touch upon this text.
The American poster baby for seafood was dragged down by a variety of things, say former leaders on the chain and restaurant analysts — together with handoffs between a mixture of traders and company mother and father and Thai Union’s mismanagement.
“Thai Union compelled big value reductions, together with many who have been penny clever and pound silly as a result of they damage gross sales,” mentioned a former Purple Lobster govt who spoke to CNN below the situation of anonymity due to a non-disclosure settlement with the corporate.
The explosive development and recognition of fast-casual chains like Chipotle and quick-service chains like Chick-fil-A over the previous 20 years additionally squeezed Purple Lobster. And years of underinvestment in Purple Lobster’s advertising and marketing, meals high quality, service and restaurant upgrades damage the chain’s capability so as to add Millennials to its core Child Boomer buyer base.
“Purple Lobster was the muse of informal eating. They’d a place of energy and prominence and revolutionized how American customers eat seafood,” mentioned Alex Susskind, a professor of meals and beverage administration at Cornell College. “Purple Lobster had unbelievable reputation amongst Child Boomers. They didn’t herald a more recent era.”
When the primary Purple Lobster opened in 1968 in Lakeland, Florida, an hour south of Orlando, informal eating was in its infancy.
The model was began by southern restaurateurs Invoice Darden and Charley Woodsby. Darden owned a number of Howard Johnson’s eating places, one of many first informal eating ideas.
“Our motto was casual and household costs,” Woodsby later said. They noticed a possibility to deliver seafood to landlocked folks at extra reasonably priced costs than fine-dining eating places.
“In most of center America, you couldn’t get first rate seafood. Purple Lobster introduced it to the plenty,” mentioned Jonathan Maze, the editor in chief at Restaurant Enterprise Journal, a commerce publication. “Purple Lobster was a part of this informal eating revolution.”
Simply two years into Darden and Woodsby’s enterprise, Normal Mills acquired the model. Normal Mills owned manufacturers like Wheaties, Cheerios and Betty Crocker, and the corporate needed to enter the restaurant business with Purple Lobster’s 5 no-frills eating places.
By the early Nineteen Seventies, with Normal Mills’ promoting muscle behind it, Purple Lobster opened eating places throughout the South.
Purple Lobster rose rapidly and was the primary informal eating chain to promote on community tv, in keeping with a Harvard Enterprise College study. Purple Lobster additionally developed the primary nationwide seafood distribution system within the Nineteen Seventies.
“Many diners most popular their seafood fried in these days, and Purple Lobster’s hush puppies might be thought-about an early ‘signature merchandise,’” Joe Lee, the primary common supervisor at Purple Lobster and later its president, mentioned in a journal article. “Households have been welcomed with excessive chairs and a 59-cent baby’s plate.”
By 1978, Purple Lobster had 236 eating places and $291 million in gross sales. It had 372 eating places and $834 million in gross sales in 1985.
In 1995, Normal Mills spun off its restaurant division into a brand new firm, Darden Eating places, named for Purple Lobster founder Invoice Darden. The corporate initially included the legacy Purple Lobster chain and Olive Backyard, an upstart chain Normal Mills had began in 1982.
However Purple Lobster fell behind its sister model Olive Backyard below Darden.
By 2008, Olive Backyard’s gross sales had eclipsed Purple Lobster’s. Darden additionally acquired fast-growing chains resembling Longhorn Steakhouse, Capital Grille and Yard Home.
“Darden stopped investing in Purple Lobster. Issues slowly deteriorated,” Les Foreman, a director of operations and divisional vice chairman at Purple Lobster from 2002 to 2022, informed CNN. Purple Lobster’s gross sales started declining and Darden prioritized investments in its different manufacturers.
Darden quickly confronted strain from activist traders pushing the corporate to separate in two.
Darden responded to activist strain by saying plans in 2013 to sell Red Lobster, separating the chain from the remainder of its enterprise.
The next yr, Darden sold Red Lobster to Golden Gate Capital, a personal fairness agency, for $2.1 billion. To assist fund the deal, Purple Lobster spun off its actual property property in a transaction referred to as a sale leaseback settlement. Purple Lobster had lengthy owned its personal actual property however would now be paying hire to lease its eating places.
Sale leasebacks are quite common within the restaurant business, however the association wound up hurting Purple Lobster as a result of it grew to become caught with leases it not might afford to pay.
“That produced value pressures on Purple Lobster that they’ve by no means had earlier than,” mentioned analyst John Gordon. “It grew to become an issue.”
On the identical time, fast-casual and quick-service eating places grew with decrease costs, 1000’s of recent drive-thru areas and on-line supply. These chains pressured the informal eating sector.
Informal eating has slipped from 36% of whole restaurant business gross sales in 2013 to 31% in 2023, in keeping with Technomic, a restaurant analysis agency.
Purple Lobster’s controlling shareholder Thai Union additionally damage the model, say former staff and analysts.
Thai Union was a high provider of shrimp to Purple Lobster for greater than 20 years. In 2016, Thai Union took a $575 million minority stake within the model. In 2020, Thai Union deepened its monetary curiosity in Purple Lobster.
Thai Union noticed a possibility to develop its enterprise and likewise turn out to be an even bigger provider to Purple Lobster.
However Thai Union “didn’t have any concept about operating a restaurant firm in the US,” mentioned former Purple Lobster divisional vice chairman Les Foreman.
“It was depressing working there for the final yr and a half I used to be there,” he mentioned. “It was only a matter of (Thai Union) chopping prices in every single place they may.”
Thai Union reduce out longtime Purple Lobster suppliers to distribute extra seafood to eating places itself, mentioned a former Purple Lobster govt who spoke to CNN below the situation of anonymity due to an NDA. Thai Union modified the menu based mostly on cost-cutting selections and executives’ tastes.
The menu selections have been pushed by “govt opinion,” not buyer preferences, the previous govt mentioned.
It additionally examined squeezing Purple Lobster’s waitstaff to the breaking level to avoid wasting on labor prices, switching from waiters protecting three tables to 10.
Purple Lobster executives started to run for the doorways below Thai Union’s administration, leading to an enormous quantity of C-suite churn. In 2021 and 2022, Purple Lobster introduced on a brand new CEO, chief advertising and marketing officer, chief monetary officer and chief data officer. All left the corporate inside two years.
Then got here the all-you-can-eat shrimp mishap final yr.
Limitless shrimp was an annual limited-time provide for Purple Lobster for 20 years. However Thai Union noticed it as a solution to unload the mountains of shrimp it was catching and made it a everlasting menu merchandise as an alternative.
“In the event you have been a big shrimp firm based mostly in Thailand, it will be a good suggestion,” mentioned the opposite former Purple Lobster govt who spoke with CNN.
However it backfired for Purple Lobster, and it wasn’t simply because shrimp wasn’t worthwhile sufficient on the seafood chain. It brought on a cascade of issues as prospects sat at tables for lengthy stretches of time, consuming course after course of shrimp, the previous govt mentioned. This slowed down service and created longer wait instances — precisely what the chain didn’t want as folks packed within the door for the prospect to seize infinite fistfuls of shrimp.
“We have been anticipating a rise of 20% in buyer site visitors, however the precise quantity was as much as 40%,” Thai Union CEO Thiraphong Chansiri mentioned in November.
Two months later, Thai Union mentioned it will divest from Purple Lobster and take a $530 million loss on its funding. The corporate blamed the pandemic, in addition to “sustained business headwinds, greater rates of interest and rising materials and labor prices.”
“I’m going to cease consuming lobster,” Chansiri mentioned this yr.