A model of this story appeared in CNN’s What Issues publication. To get it in your inbox, join free here.
CNN
—
There’s an inclination on this heated political local weather to easily reject people who find themselves saying false issues and to write down off conspiracy theorists writ massive.
However because the US approaches the third straight election by which misinformation — and the battle towards it — is predicted to play a task, it’s vital to grasp what’s driving individuals who don’t imagine in US elections.
CNN’s Donie O’Sullivan and his group have an hourlong documentary, “MisinfoNation: The Trump Trustworthy,” airing on “The Entire Story with Anderson Cooper” on Sunday at 8 p.m. ET.
I talked to O’Sullivan in regards to the documentary, by which he has some frank and disarming talks with individuals about what has shaken their perception within the US. However he paints an alarming image in regards to the rise of fringe actions within the nation.
Our dialog, carried out by telephone and edited for size, is under:
The fringes have contaminated the mainstream
WOLF: What had been you attempting to perform with this mission?
O’SULLIVAN: A lot of mainstream American politics now’s being contaminated and affected by what is occurring on what was as soon as thought of the actual fringes — fringe platforms, fringe personalities.
And I believe actually what we wish to do on this present is illustrate how these personalities could also be pushing falsehoods, however they’re not fringe. That is all taking place proper now. And it’s having a giant impact on our democracy.
WOLF: Your demeanor once you conduct these interviews with individuals saying incorrect issues is pleasant. It’s respectful. I used to be disarmed by that as a result of, when you do level out inaccurate issues individuals say throughout these interviews, you additionally ended up speaking to individuals as an alternative of disagreeing with them. How do you go about conducting these interviews?
O’SULLIVAN: I don’t view my job as going on the market to vary individuals’s minds. There are many different individuals who can try this or who can strive to do this. I wish to hear what these individuals imagine and why they imagine it.
Clearly, once we current it to our viewers, we are going to make sure that individuals have the details. However I believe it’s crucial to enter each single considered one of these interviews open-minded and with an understanding that we’re all human.
Plenty of the nation believes these things. The most recent polling — I believe it’s about a third of Americans who imagine that Joe Biden didn’t legitimately win the final election. I take into consideration a quarter of Americans believed that January 6 was staged by the FBI or they’d a hand in it. It’s tens of tens of millions of individuals.
Plenty of these individuals are fairly regular. They’ve obtained jobs, they’ve obtained households, they’re concerned of their group. However for one motive or one other, they simply go off on this election stuff or they go off on QAnon or no matter it’s.
So I believe it’s actually vital that we deal with all people with respect, perhaps even when they don’t essentially wish to present it to us.
Among the individuals we’ve met alongside the way in which, we’ve proven bits of their interviews on air. Rachel Powell is serving time in federal jail for what she did on January 6. She can be a mother and a grandmother. Once we printed a few of that interview, I had a great deal of individuals in feedback on-line saying, “Why are you humanizing this girl?” To which my response was: “She’s a human being.”
O’Sullivan asks Rachel Powell, going to jail for Jan. 6, if she blames Trump. Hear her response
WOLF: It’s not your job to vary individuals’s minds, however I ponder, after reporting this documentary, what you suppose will be completed to get individuals to comply with the identical set of details?
O’SULLIVAN: I would not have options. I believe listening and speaking to individuals is a big a part of this. We talked to Joe Black, a man in Colorado.
(Word: They meet at a Donald Trump rally, and O’Sullivan calls Black and finally travels to Black’s dwelling, the place they take a look at what Black sees on social media versus what O’Sullivan sees.)
He didn’t even know that CNN would ever do a reality examine of Joe Biden.
(Word: CNN does many.)
It’s opening individuals’s eyes in that method a bit. However I believe extra importantly, it’s being prepared to have the dialog within the first place. Being truly prepared to sit down down and speak with of us within the first place.
And I believe a variety of readers most likely have individuals of their households or mates who’ve dived into this world of election lies or conspiracy theories. From the specialists that I’ve spoken to about this, whether or not it’s cults or conspiracy theories, empathy is a giant a part of it. You’re not going to persuade anybody of details by beginning off telling them they’re an fool.
WOLF: A theme all through the present is a perception amongst Christian nationalists that the US is a Christian nation and that Christianity is laced all through the Structure and the founding paperwork. There are some attention-grabbing moments within the present the place it dawns on individuals that truly the phrase “God” doesn’t seem within the Structure. Was that one thing you anticipated? Or is it one thing you stumbled upon?
O’SULLIVAN: There are such a lot of strands to what’s taking place within the nation proper now, particularly on the subject of belief and mistrust in democracy, and Christian nationalism is considered one of them. We wished to indicate on this documentary how two of those strands are sort of intertwining.
In terms of Christian nationalism particularly, the explanations that we went down that route are 1) it’s one thing I hear on a regular basis at these occasions and a pair of) there’s rising consciousness about it.
Tim Alberta had an excellent e-book final yr about it.
(Word: Watch CNN’s Christiane Amanpour interview Alberta.)
Extra so than the rest, it was simply from talking to evangelical and different Christian pastors who’re actually fearful proper now about what they’re seeing, how their religion is being weaponized in a method to assault democracy.
Plenty of it’s not new by way of this type of speedy weaponization of conservative Christianity, if you wish to name it that, however I believe there’s an urgency now that we hadn’t seen earlier than.
Pastors have seen members of their congregation, members of their flock who go away as a result of their sermons weren’t political sufficient or weren’t immediately supporting Trump because the candidate.
In terms of God within the Structure, pastor Caleb Campbell places it fairly effectively within the documentary when he says that he sits down with fellow evangelicals — he’s a theological evangelical and lots of people assume that the Christian God is everywhere in the Structure and the founding paperwork, which isn’t the case in any respect.
There’s nothing incorrect with being a Christian. There’s nothing incorrect with being a patriot. However what is admittedly taking place with Christian nationalism is that they’re pushing a really particular kind of Christianity on the expense of different individuals’s freedoms.
See what occurs when Trump supporter talks to CNN reporter in regards to the Structure
WOLF: You’ve lined these fringe actions, however you’ve additionally lined among the social media stuff and I ponder what you suppose individuals ought to know in regards to the rise of those sorts of fringe social media platforms — Telegram is the one featured within the documentary — which are gaining traction.
O’SULLIVAN: Lots of people obtained kicked off the key social media platforms after January 6. Trump obtained kicked off, however I believe what lots of people don’t notice is that a variety of his supporters obtained banned too as a result of they had been sharing election conspiracy theories or issues like that.
We meet a kind of individuals within the documentary, Joe Black, who stated he obtained kicked off Fb after he shared a meme about January 6.
(Word: Black says he felt remoted by not with the ability to do easy issues like purchase objects on Fb.)
It has pushed individuals into these darker corners of the web that may be much more excessive and much more radicalizing. It’s a dilemma, proper? As a result of main social media platforms like Fb have these guidelines. However what occurs once you kick a variety of these individuals off is usually they go to platforms which are extra excessive.
Clearly, Twitter, X, has modified loads. (Word: Twitter has modified loads since a lot of its moderation protections had been ended after it was purchased by Elon Musk.) However I believe simply general, in 2016, all of the guards had been down when it got here to social media. There have been Russian trolls and every thing else.
After which in 2020 there was a giant crackdown from the social media platforms, which obtained an enormous quantity of blowback from conservatives. And now I really feel like we’re in a complete new panorama — it has completely modified once more.
WOLF: There’s a girl you interview, Rachel Powell, a mom who’s on her method to jail once you speak to her. Is she in jail now? Are you continue to in touch?
O’SULLIVAN: She is in jail. I truly obtained a letter from her this week from jail in West Virginia. She despatched the letter, I believe, greater than a month in the past. But it surely solely arrived to me this week.
She’s hanging on to that hope that if Trump will get reelected, she’ll be pardoned. Clearly, there’s loads using on this election for her. It’s attention-grabbing, as a result of clearly Trump has, notably over the previous few months, has actually began spotlighting the individuals who had been prosecuted for January 6 and has very a lot been sort of portraying them as martyrs.
She’s in jail. She’s obtained a cellmate. But it surely doesn’t look like the assumption in Trump or something like that has waned in any method.