A model of this story appeared in CNN’s What Issues e-newsletter. To get it in your inbox, join free here.
CNN
—
The approaching months are going to offer former President Donald Trump with the truth of campaigning from outdoors a courtroom.
He has, heretofore, chosen to attend varied courtroom dates. When his criminal trial in Manhattan gets under way in late March, he might conceivably have locked up the GOP nomination however should attend the anticipated six-week trial or ask the decide to be excused.
We received a preview of this unprecedented felony trial combined with a presidential marketing campaign on Thursday at a key listening to within the New York felony case. This time, Trump had a alternative – he may also have attended a listening to in Georgia, the place District Lawyer Fani Willis, who’s overseeing his election interference case within the state, faces allegations of misconduct associated to her relationship with a prosecutor she appointed to supervise the case, a cleaning soap opera on the aspect of the Trump trials.
Trump routinely manipulates the media spectacle outdoors courtroom by rambling on about his felony prosecutions and his political rivals. The small print fluctuate, however the primary speaking factors keep largely the identical and are repeated on a loop: political persecution, crime-ridden cities and his robust polling.
Right here’s a few of what Trump mentioned Thursday in New York earlier than heading into the courtroom, together with context.
It’s not clear what authorized students Trump is referring to, however he says he’s not responsible of crimes in all four of the criminal cases he’s going through. He’ll repeat variations of “this isn’t a criminal offense” as a type of mantra all through these feedback.
This explicit case, brought by Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg, pertains to hush-money funds to squash three separate, adverse tales earlier than the 2016 election.
Funds had been made to a former Trump Tower doorman by the mum or dad firm of the Nationwide Enquirer, American Media Inc., to purchase the doorman’s story about an alleged Trump affair and Trump-fathered baby. It was a “catch and kill” effort by the Enquirer, which by no means revealed the story it had purchased. The Trump Group has denied the affair allegation.
Six-figure funds had been additionally made by AMI to “catch and kill” the story of a former Playboy mannequin, Karen McDougal, who mentioned she had an affair with Trump. He denies it.
Trump’s former legal professional Michael Cohen additionally paid $130,000 to the adult-film actress Stormy Daniels by a shell firm days earlier than the 2016 presidential election. Daniels said she had an affair with Trump in 2006. Trump denies the allegation. However he compensated Cohen for the Daniels cost, and his firm described the cost to Daniels as authorized bills.
Cohen pleaded responsible to federal costs associated to the funds and served time in jail. Trump was by no means charged by federal prosecutors, maybe partly as a result of the Division of Justice has a coverage of not prosecuting presidents.
The crime Trump is now accused of in New York is 34 counts of falsifying business records and misrepresenting the funds as a way to affect the 2016 election.
Claiming violent crime in cites, particularly these run by Democrats, is considered one of Trump’s favourite speaking factors. The concept that violent crime is at an “all-time excessive” is totally unfaithful, as CNN’s Daniel Dale wrote final October.
Crime charges have fallen since then. In knowledge launched by the New York City Police Department, charges of homicide, rape, assault, housebreaking and automobile theft had been all down in January 2024 in contrast with January 2023. Theft and grand larceny elevated. Dale identified in his reality test that the precise violent crime charges had been a lot larger a long time in the past, when these horrible data had been set.
It’s additionally value noting that Trump is attempting to match his white-collar crimes with violent crimes, which looks as if a false comparability. There are nonviolent crimes which can be nonetheless crimes. Whether or not Trump is responsible can be as much as a jury.
Trump typically repeats this declare that his 4, separate felony trials are a coordinated “election interference” scheme. Not solely does it flip the script on the truth that it’s he who has been charged in state courtroom in Georgia and federal courtroom in Washington, DC, with election interference, however it additionally performs into his bigger declare that something against him is a part of a “witch hunt.”
It’s false and ridiculous to assume that these circumstances are all coordinated by the Biden administration. A particular counsel, Jack Smith, appointed to be autonomous from the Justice Division, is overseeing the 2 federal felony prosecutions. Bragg is overseeing this hush-money prosecution. Willis is overseeing the Georgia state election case.
Anybody rating the severity of trials in opposition to Trump would most likely prefer to see his federal election interference trial go first on the calendar. However the decide in Manhattan has crammed Trump’s calendar on the finish of March, when that federal trial might theoretically have taken place. The federal trial date is on maintain whereas the Supreme Courtroom considers Trump’s argument that he has absolute immunity from prosecution for acts carried out whereas he was president.
What is that this? Whereas Trump first alleged that Biden “stuffed” the Manhattan DA’s workplace final 12 months earlier than he was indicted, this new element is a head scratcher. Dale explains that Matthew Colangelo is a former Justice Division official who’s now a senior counsel to Bragg. Their relationship predates Colangelo’s time on the Division of Justice.
There may be additionally a sample of Trump in search of to query individuals within the justice system. In his civil fraud trial within the case introduced by New York Lawyer Common Letitia James, for example, he seized on a clerk to the decide and alleged she was tied to Democratic Sen. Chuck Schumer, the Senate majority chief. The small print will change, however Trump discovering an individual to demonize is predictable.
He’s looping. See above.
Trump is definitely main, and maybe untouchable, within the race for the Republican nomination. In lots of polls, he does at present have a slim lead in a hypothetical matchup in opposition to Biden.
However his lead is much from unprecedented. Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan are Republicans who received true landslide victories, carrying practically each state in a normal election. Nobody is speaking about that type of victory for Trump.
There may be not now and there has by no means been proof of systemic or widespread dishonest to defeat Trump in both 2016 or 2020, though he has alleged as a lot for each elections.
It’s definitely true that political rivals in weak democracies and autocracies face political prosecutions. Have a look at Alexey Navalny and a number of different critics of President Vladimir Putin who’ve been jailed after questionable prosecutions in Russia.
However to match the US judicial system to that of a banana republic is ridiculous. Juries will decide Trump’s guilt or innocence. A Supreme Courtroom with three Trump-appointed justices has remaining evaluation of the system that’s prosecuting him.
By “they,” Trump presumably means the entire distinct authorities attempting to prosecute him. By “our course of,” he means his technique of delay, delay, delay.
Trump’s authorized technique is to win the election. If he wins in November, the possible consequence is that his two federal circumstances, if unresolved, would go away.
State prosecutions are completely different. It’s not clear {that a} state couldn’t prosecute a president or a president-elect, however any prosecutions would definitely be difficult.
Trump’s prosecutions truly appear to have helped him within the Republican nomination race. His base has rallied round him, and his rivals have been unable to realize a severe foothold.
Really, given the selection, Trump has continuously attended courtroom hearings over marketing campaign occasions – both in his felony circumstances or in his $370 million civil fraud trial, the place a verdict is anticipated as quickly as Friday. Dale writes in a fact check that, no, Trump was not caught in courtroom immediately. The previous president didn’t want to seem for this listening to. He had no South Carolina occasions scheduled and plans to fly again to Florida after the listening to.
When he says “different individuals,” he’s referring to former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley, his final remaining severe rival for the Republican nomination. Polling suggests he has a commanding lead over Haley in her dwelling state because the GOP main there approaches.
Right here, he’s each looping and making the provocative declare that he could possibly be responsible however not be a felony.
Trump has constructed his presidential marketing campaign round two predominant pillars: retribution for his 2020 loss, which he nonetheless doesn’t settle for, and being harder on border coverage.
Right here he marries the dual pillars of his marketing campaign with the phrase “Biden migrant crime.”
In New York, officers are coping with a crush of asylum-seeking migrants who’ve been bused to town from Texas and elsewhere. New York’s mayor has complained concerning the pressure on town and its companies. And he has additionally not too long ago helped feed the notion that crime within the metropolis is being perpetrated by migrants, who below federal guidelines can’t receive a piece allow till they’ve been within the nation for six months.
Greater than 150,000 migrants have arrived in New York Metropolis, and there have been viral movies of migrants concerned in felony exercise. However as The New York Times notes, regardless of the rising variety of migrants within the metropolis, violent crime has dropped.
Wait, what? Trump has persistently refused to launch his tax returns so his declare that he paid $300 million in taxes “over the time frame” is unverifiable. If an individual is a money-making billionaire, it’s doable that paying $300 million represents a decrease tax price than many different Individuals. Is he referring to federal taxes? State taxes?
We do know, as a result of some years of his returns had been leaked, that there have been years wherein he paid no federal earnings tax as a result of he claimed large losses from earlier years. Within the 12 months he received the White Home and in his first 12 months as president, he paid $750 in federal earnings taxes.
We additionally know that Trump’s normal outlook on taxes is to pay as little as doable.